Reel Politique: DVD Review, The Nines
Thursday, January 31st, 2008The Nines would be utterly incomprehensible if it weren’t for an anonymous extra on the new DVD. Among a plethora of ultimately unhelpful supplements is a short film that writer and director John August made a few years earlier called God. This short stars Melissa McCarthy (Gilmore Girls) as a young housewife who has a deep gossipy telephone relationship with God, who calls her frequently. Essentially the short blends a high school girl telephone lifestyle with a humanizing view of God freed of theological baggage.
McCarthy pops up again in The Nines, playing three characters, one of them the girl from God. The Nines itself is divided into three successive stories. The first tale concerns a hot young TV crime show actor named Gary (Ryan Reynolds) who has a public meltdown and is confined by his agent and a publicist to a house owned by a writer who is off making a TV pilot. McCarthy plays the publicist, and apparently her character is the same one from God. How this confluence works ultimately is ambiguous, but in any case, on a meta level she is also protecting her pal God from realizing that he is just playing a game by living someone else’s lifestyle. The other two stories concern Gavin (Reynolds again) who is a gay TV writer trying to mount a new show and whose exploits are followed by a reality TV crew. The third and final episode is the pilot that Gavin is working on, featuring in its cast the same actors who appear in the other two tales. There are also various overlaps and connections among the three stories.
When an innovative screenwriter comes along they are almost always compared to Tarantino or to Charles Kaufman. The specter of the Tarantino influence loomed with August’s first filmed script, Go, which played with chronology in the Tarantino manner, but which was probably misleading as to August’s real interests as a filmmaker (he soon ended up a collaborator of Tim Burton’s). August is less a Tarantino than a Richard Kelly. Left to his own devices, August naturally gravitates to obscurantist metaphysical tales on multiple levels.
Like Dante’s Divine Comedy, everything in The Nines comes in threes. Besides the three stories, there are three main characters symbolic perhaps of different Jungian archetypes. Reynolds, regardless of his identity, is always God, who imagines different worlds and casts himself in a key role to see what being a human being is like (that’s a guess). McCarthy falls into the role of aide-du-camp. In the first tale she is a handler, in the second the writer’s best friend (whom he betrays in order to get his show accepted by the network, though it isn’t), and in the third she plays the wife character in the pilot. The third character is a trickster-Anima archetype played by Hope Davis, a seductive neighbor in the first, a double-crossing TV exec in the second, and a hiker in the pilot. Her role, much as one can understand it, is to lure God back to his Olympian heights and abandon these fake worlds he has created.
As a puzzle film The Nines is modestly entertaining, but one watches it as one does Donnie Darko, with little hope that its mysteries will be revealed. McCarthy appears in a coda, which suggests that she was really the main character all along, but it remains unclear if the God worlds she has visited are dreams she has had or real parallel universes she has visited, or what. By watching all the extras on the DVD one can piece together an interpretation like the one above, although there is no definitive answer offered up.
The Nines came out on DVD from Sony Pictures Home Entertainment on Tuesday, January 29, 2008 (retailing for $24.95) and is packed with extras. The disc comes with two audio commentary tracks, the first with August and Reynolds, the second, recorded later, with August, McCarthy, and the film’s editor, Douglas Crise. After his work in a variety of films, from The Amityville Horror to Smokin’ Aces, Reynolds (who also started out in sitcoms — Two Guys, a Girl, and a Pizza Place), looks to have the potential of becoming another Tom Hanks, adept in comedy, drama, action, anything. He is attractive yet changeable, charismatic and generous to co-stars (whom he makes look better). He needs only a break-out hit to put him at People-level public consciousness, but one suspects on the basis of his yak track that Reynolds is terribly shy and awkward in an unscripted world, though that didn’t stop the similarly afflicted Robert DeNiro. The second track is cozier, but in the end offers mostly technical and background information. We do learn that much of the first two stories are autobiographical and in part based on his work on two failed TV shows, D.C. and Alaska, though August doesn’t admit to hitting a female executive as the Gavin character does (the only woman associated with August’s two shows is E. Monique Floyd). We also learn that August has a penchant for upside down cars, and can see that he is fond of characters stretching out on the floor or ground.
There are also nine deleted or extended scenes, with an optional commentary by August and Crise. Mostly the come from the first segment, and one of them expands Gary’s character by showing him opportunistically getting a blow job from a delivery boy. The last deleted is an alternative ending, though it is similar to the standing ending.
In addition there is a script to storyboard comparison, a brief “making of” that reveals more facets of the film’s mysteries, a short photo gallery, and the God short. Finally, there is a whole raft of trailers: a Blu-Ray promo, Dragon Wars, Southland Tales, Revolver, Resident Evil: Extinction, Boogeyman 2, Gabriel, Slipstream, Across the Universe, Romance and Cigarettes, Zombie Strippers, Black Water, We Own the Night, and one for the first season of Damages on DVD.
























